The Dickensian Christmas Carol Blog
William Mortensen Vaughan's reviews and ratings of (and quizzes on) adaptations of A Christmas Carol, by Charles Dickens
Monday, January 9, 2023
Quiz 3 on "A Topper Christmas Carol" (1953), Starring Leo G. Carroll
2. Who knocks Mrs. Cratchit onto her Christmas Dinner table so hard that it collapses under her, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
3. Whom does the Ghost of Christmas Past show "the Scrooge," in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
4. What does the neighbor boy do to "the Scrooge," in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
5. What does the neighbor boy give "the Scrooge" for Christmas, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
6. What does the neighbor boy claim he does with the sort of item he gives "the Scrooge" for Christmas, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
7. What is Thelma's surname, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
8. What is Thelma's marital status, and who invited her (presumably) to attend the Christmas Party at the Topper Residence, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
9. Whom does Tiny Tim want to grow up to be like, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
10. Who, besides Thelma, attends the Christmas Party at the Topper Residence, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Answers will be published by January 25, 2023.
Quiz by William Mortensen Vaughan
Answers to Quiz 2 on "A Topper Christmas Carol" (1953), Starring Leo G. Carroll
1. What is the neighbor boy's first name, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Timmy.
2. What is Topper's first name?
Cosmo.
3. Whom does the Ghost of Christmas Past resemble, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Marion Kerby.
4. How far back in time does the Ghost of Christmas Past take "the Scrooge," in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Twenty-five years.
5. What is Mrs. Topper's first name?
Henrietta
6. Where does Mr. Topper work?
At a bank.
7. What game does Topper usually play on Sunday?
Golf.
8. How many people attended Mr. and Mrs. Topper's wedding?
More than two hundred.
9. Whom does the Ghost of Christmas Present resemble, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
George Kerby
10. Whom does the Ghost of Christmas Future resemble, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Neil.
Quiz and Answers by William Mortensen Vaughan
Thursday, December 29, 2022
Quiz 2 on "A Topper Christmas Carol" (1953), Starring Leo G. Carroll
1. What is the neighbor boy's first name, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
2. What is Topper's first name?
3. Whom does the Ghost of Christmas Past resemble, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
4. How far back in time does the Ghost of Christmas Past take "the Scrooge," in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
5. What is Mrs. Topper's first name?
6. Where does Topper work?
7. What game does Topper usually play on Sunday?
8. How many people attended Mr. and Mrs. Topper's wedding, and where did it take place?
9. Whom does the Ghost of Christmas Present resemble, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
10. Whom does the Ghost of Christmas Future resemble, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Answers were published January 9, 2023.
Quiz by William Mortensen Vaughan
Quiz 1 on "A Topper Christmas Carol" (1953), Starring Leo G. Carroll
2. When and where does this episode take place?
3. According to whom, who "must be color blind" in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
4. Which Christmas is this, that the ghosts of the Mr. Kerby and his wife are spending with Topper? (Give an ordinal number.)
5. What is the surname of Topper's neighbor boy, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
6. What is the name of the dog, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
7. What does the dog have in common with its owners, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
8. What breed of dog appears in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
9. Who falls asleep, and dreams that he is Scrooge, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
10. Who is Katie, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Answers were published December 29, 2022.
Quiz by William Mortensen Vaughan
Answers to Quiz 1 on "A Topper Christmas Carol" (1953), Starring Leo G. Carroll
1. When and where did this episode premiere?
Friday, December 25, 1953; U.S.A.
2. When and where does this episode take place?
Circa 1955, in Topper's home, in Los Angeles
3. According to whom, who "must be color blind" in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Marion says Topper "must be color blind."
4. Which Christmas is this, that the ghosts of the Mr. Kerby and his wife are spending with Topper? (Give an ordinal number.)
First
5. What is the surname of Topper's neighbor boy, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Welch
6. What is the name of the dog, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Neil
7. What does the dog have in common with its owners, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
It's a ghost.
8. What breed of dog appears in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
St. Bernard
9. Who falls asleep, and dreams that he is Scrooge, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
Topper
10. Who is Katie, in this adaptation of A Christmas Carol?
The cook
Quiz and Answers by William Mortensen Vaughan
Thursday, December 15, 2022
Topper's Christmas Carol (1953): Review by William Mortensen Vaughan
Dates and Places of Earliest Release:
Format Reviewed: live-action television episode, streamed from YouTube
Does this adaptation mention "God" or "Christ"?
What does my wife think of this adaptation?
She's not interested in it.
Where and when does this adaptation take place?
What language and/or dialects are used?
Is this adaptation supernatural?
Is this adaptation "framed"?
Is this adaptation a musical?
How attractive and effective is the visual art?
How creative and intense are the transitions, especially when "the Scrooge" is taken from one time and/or place to another?
What bonus material is included on the tape or DVD?
Wednesday, January 12, 2022
The Annotated Christmas Carol, Edited by Michael Patrick Hearn: Review by William Mortensen Vaughan
The Annotated Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens was edited by Michael Patrick Hearn. The edition I'm reviewing was published in 2004. It is illustrated by the original illustrator of A Christmas Carol, John Leech, et al. It consists of four major sections:
- Introduction to The Annotated Christmas Carol
- The Annotated Christmas Carol
- Introduction to A Christmas Carol. In Four Staves
- A Christmas Carol. In Four Staves
The pages before the second section are numbered with lower case, Roman numerals. The Introduction to The Annotated Christmas Carol spans pages from xiii to cxiv (13 to 114, for those of you unfamiliar with Roman numerals); the previous pages include cover pages, Contents, Acknowledgments, et cetera. The introductions contain, essentially, information about three topics:
- A history of Christmas
- The life of Charles Dickens
- A history of the original and early editions of A Christmas Carol
A Christmas Carol. In Four StavesI is a copy of the 1867 edition, which was an abridged adaptation that Charles Dickens referred to while giving public readings of the novel. Included among the pages of The Annotated Christmas Carol and the abridged version are annotations, or footnotes, with explanations of archaic terms, and historical insights.
Test your knowledge of these topics by taking the following quizzes:
U N D E R C O N S T R U C T I O N ! ! !
Test your knowledge of Christmas by taking these quizzes:
Quiz 1 of [T.B.D.] on Christmas
Quiz 2 of [T.B.D.] on Christmas
Quiz 3 of [T.B.D.] on Christmas
Quiz 4 of [T.B.D.] on Christmas
Quiz 5 of [T.B.D.] on Christmas
Quiz 6 of [T.B.D.] on Christmas
Quiz 7 of [T.B.D.] on Christmas
Quiz 8 of [T.B.D.] on Christmas
Quiz 9 of [T.B.D.] on Christmas
Quiz 10 of [T.B.D.] on Christmas
Test your knowledge of Charles Dickens by taking these quizzes:
Quiz 1 of [T.B.D.] on The Life of Charles Dickens
Quiz 2 of [T.B.D.] on The Life of Charles Dickens
Test your knowledge of A Christmas Carol by taking these quizzes:
Quiz 1 of [T.B.D.] on A Christmas Carol
Quiz 2 of [T.B.D.] on A Christmas Carol
Quiz 3 of [T.B.D.] on A Christmas Carol
Quiz 4 of [T.B.D.] on A Christmas Carol
Quiz 5 of [T.B.D.] on A Christmas Carol
Review and Quizzes by William Mortensen Vaughan